Conscious vs. Unconscious Thought in Making Complicated Decisions

When faced with a difficult decision, we try to come up with the best choice by carefully considering all of the options, maybe even resorting to lists and lots of sleepless nights. So it may be surprising that recent studies have suggested that the best way to deal with complex decisions is to not think about them at all—that unconscious thought will help us make the best choices. Although this may seem like an appealing strategy, new research in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science, cautions that there are limitations in the efficacy of unconscious thought making the best decisions.

Duke University researchers John W. Payne, Adriana Samper, James R. Bettman and Mary Frances Luce had volunteers participate in a lottery choice task, where they had to pick from four various options, each with a different, but close, payoff. The volunteers were divided into three groups for this task: one group was instructed to think about the task for a given amount of time, another group was told to think about the task for as long as they wanted and the last group was distracted before making their selection (thus, unconsciously thinking about the task). A second experiment was similarly set up, except that there were substantial differences in the payoffs of the different options.

The researchers found that there are situations where unconscious thought will not result in the best choice being selected. The findings showed that in some instances (when the payoffs were similar), thinking about the task for as long as it takes to make a decision was as effective as unconscious thought, resulting in the most profitable options being chosen. However, when there were large differences in the amount of money to be won, mulling over the decision at their own pace led the volunteers to larger payoffs than unconscious thought. The volunteers who were told to consciously think about the decision for a specific amount of time performed poorly in both experiments. The authors explain that those volunteers had “too much time to think” about the task and that their attention shifted “to information of lesser relevance,” resulting in less profitable decisions..

These results suggest that although unconscious thought may help us make the right decision in a number of instances, occasionally it is better to rely on conscious thought and really focus on the problem at hand.


I know it this sort of thing with unconscious thought occurs because I have experienced acute episodes of unconsious thought, especially when I was a child-it seemed to decline over time as I got older though.

It only ever happened whilst doing strong physical exertion in sport. I would lose conscious awareness for around 10-15 seconds, in which time I would often do something particularly difficult. I often had to ask my team members who were congratuating me what had happened, I had no recolleciton of it, but it was always when something difficult had to be done and required intense focus, and it seemed to work. I was also amongst the very top of these sporting pursuits for my age.

Just thought i’d mention it, as I havent heard of this anywhere else. It kind of took away from the experience though, when you cant actually remember doing what you achieved.

APS regularly opens certain online articles for discussion on our website. Effective February 2021, you must be a logged-in APS member to post comments. By posting a comment, you agree to our Community Guidelines and the display of your profile information, including your name and affiliation. Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations present in article comments are those of the writers and do not necessarily reflect the views of APS or the article’s author. For more information, please see our Community Guidelines.

Please login with your APS account to comment.