Silent Treatment

Uncovering the Nature and Consequences of Ostracism

This is a photo of a group of young girls at a sleepover, excluding one girl on the floor. Let me tell you a story. It takes place when I was in kindergarten, so picture me shorter, with jaunty green ribbons on the ends of my braids and bright red sandals (I was going through my Wizard of Oz phase). It was lunchtime, and emboldened by the sort of youthful enthusiasm that comes from eating four chocolate chip cookies within 2 minutes, I approached two of the popular kids in my class and asked if I could join their game. They were playing “trains,” a simple game that consisted of creating a conga line (the train) and chugging off around the playground. To my surprise, they said yes; all I had to do was wait at the “station” until they came to pick me up, and then we would all chug around the playground together. I nodded enthusiastically, green ribbons bobbing, and off went the train, leaving me to wait at the station.

And wait.

And wait.

And wait.

I watched as the train picked up passengers from all over the playground, until it had collected enough children to qualify as an actual mass transit system. But it did not stop for me. And even now, I can still remember the dizzying array of emotions that flooded my little five-year old self as I watched that train weaving joyously around the playground: disbelief, injustice, humiliation, hope (when the train came toward me), despair (when it laughingly veered away from me), anger, sadness, hopelessness, pain, pain, pain. I waited at my station (i.e., Loserville) until the bell rang, signaling the end of lunch, and I dragged my little red shoes toward my classroom, trying very hard not to sob.

This was the first time I had been rejected by my peers, and it was so unexpected and so unjust that it left me inconsolable. Nothing made me feel better; not the commiserations of my family when I told them about the incident after school, or double helpings of chocolate ice-cream (the universal cure-all for five -year olds), or my childish schemes for vengeance (I’m Sicilian). Looking back, that episode created the first crack in my social invincibility armor; it is when I first realized that maybe I was not quite as universally loveable as I had previously thought (or as my parents had implied). It made me question everything — my value as a playmate, the motives of my classmates, and the pleasantness of train travel in general.

But what I find surprising is that, looking back on that episode, the feelings associated with the rejection are as fresh and raw as if it had occurred only yesterday. I know for a fact that other traumatic episodes took place during that same year —  a particularly nasty fall off a tree in the back garden, the death of my beloved goldfish Mr. Fish (who committed suicide by jumping out of his tank and into the path of our voracious vacuum cleaner), my mother getting a very unflattering perm (it was the 80s) — but none of these memories, not even those involving physical pain, still incite such a visceral response in me over 30 years later.

This playground incident, coupled with similar incidents throughout my life, spurred my interest in ostracism — the act of being excluded and ignored. This interest skyrocketed during my PhD research when I had the opportunity to interview real world targets (i.e., those who are ostracized) and sources (i.e., ostracizers) of long-term ostracism in the community. These interviews opened my eyes to the fact that forms of ostracism, such as the silent treatment, were being used to devastating effect in homes, businesses, and schools around the world. The stories that these people shared with me were often extraordinary. Some were unexpected; for instance, one woman claimed that her husband had trained the dog to ostracize her and had wanted advice on how to get the dog’s attention back. (I recommended visiting a vet for training advice and, in the meantime, filling her pockets with bacon.) Other stories were simply heartbreaking. One young woman in high school was ignored by every single one of her classmates for several months. She found this widespread, unremitting ostracism so distressing that it led her to attempt suicide. Many targets reported experiencing ostracism episodes that lasted years, even decades, from their loved ones, primarily parents or spouses. These targets lamented that receiving the silent treatment from their loved ones meant that they dreaded going home at night — their homes were a place of ongoing distress and angst rather than a refuge from the outside world.

The insights that these interviews have provided, and the questions they have raised, have been at the center of all of my research to date. And although these interviews have provided almost unlimited research ideas, there are three avenues of research that I anticipate will hold my interest throughout my career as an ostracism researcher.

Ameliorating the Aversive Effects of Ostracism

During every interview with, or in every email that I receive from, targets of long-term ostracism, I am asked: How do you fix the aversive effects of ostracism? What can be done to make the pain go away? Unfortunately, most research to date has focused on uncovering the deleterious effects of being ostracized on thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. There has been far less research on how to ameliorate these aversive effects. Developing strategies to ameliorate the aversive effects of ostracism is now the central focus of my research. It is a challenging research aim; in fact, many of the strategies we have tried (social and clinical) have had little impact on ameliorating the immediate effects of ostracism. However, there is promising evidence that the strategies we are investigating play a role in moderating the long-term effects of ostracism.

Given that the development of amelioration strategies will inevitably have a profound impact on both the field of ostracism and the community in general, this is an area that should be receiving far more attention from ostracism researchers.

Sources of Ostracism: The Other Half of the Puzzle

Another question that I am typically asked by targets of long-term ostracism is: “How do you stop an ostracism episode?” That is, once you are being ignored, is there any way of making the source pay attention to you once again? Unfortunately, this is yet another brilliant question that we can’t yet (fully) answer. One reason for this is that we know very little about sources of ostracism and the ways in which they ostracize others.

To date, ostracism researchers have been overwhelmingly focused on investigating the ostracism experience from the perspective of the target, which is understandable; they are the center of the episode, and we want to know how they feel (psychologically and physiologically) and how they behave as a consequence. And yet by focusing almost exclusively on targets, we are missing half of the ostracism puzzle. Who are the ostracizers? Why do they choose to ostracize rather than use other forms of interpersonal conflict? Are some people more likely to become ostracizers? What are the psychological and physiological costs and benefits of engaging in this kind of behavior toward others, both in the short and long term? What factors will lead them to curtail their ostracism episode?

Clearly, sources of ostracism warrant experimental investigation. However, inducing participants to ostracize others within a laboratory context is difficult to accomplish. Our lab is currently working on paradigms that will allow us to examine sources of ostracism, as well as developing measures that help us to uncover sources’ underlying personality traits. Ultimately, understanding the role of sources — their motives, their desires — may help us to determine both methods that can curtail ostracism episodes and better strategies to ameliorate the aversive effects of ostracism.

Paradigms: Bringing Ostracism From the Real World Into the Laboratory

Ultimately, the potential to investigate sources or amelioration strategies in the laboratory depends upon having paradigms that induce convincing ostracism episodes. One of my favorite aspects of research is devising paradigms, with the aim of creating ostracism situations in the laboratory that reflect the complexity of the ostracism experience in the real world. (The fact that one of the paradigms I helped to devise involves being ostracized during a train ride is completely coincidental. Completely coincidental.)

The most recent paradigm devised, in conjunction with Rani Goodacre, is “O-Cam” — a paradigm that allows participants to be ignored or included during a (pre-taped) web conference, thereby mimicking the silent treatment situations that are common in the real world. (For a demonstration of the paradigm, see www.psych.usyd.edu.au/research/ostracism/, username: guest; password: Bach).

We have also just finished a study comparing the effectiveness of the most popular ostracism paradigms. Researchers in the field often use ostracism paradigms interchangeably, even though they induce very different types of ostracism (e.g., exclusion during a task/game versus being ignored during a conversation). Our findings to date suggest that these paradigms lead to different psychological outcomes. This needs to be kept in mind when devising studies and making conclusions about the applicability of the findings.

Ultimately, the more paradigms we devise, particularly if they assess different aspects of ostracism or different ostracism experiences, the greater the opportunity of uncovering as much as possible about this powerful phenomenon.

References and Further Reading:

Goodacre, R. & Zadro, L. (2010). O-Cam: A new paradigm for investigating the effects of ostracism. Behavioral Research Methods, 42, 768–774.

Zadro, L., Arriaga, X. B., & Williams, K. D. (2008). Relational ostracism. In J. P. Forgas & J. Fitness (Eds.), Social relationships: Cognitive, affective, and motivational processes (pp. 305–320). New York, NY: Psychology Press.

Observer Vol.26, No.2 February, 2013

Leave a comment below and continue the conversation.

Comments

Great article. Laughed out loud twice!
Your point about the study of the victim making for only half the truth is right.
I have been the subject of the silent treatment from someone I loved very much. But 18 months down the road, I am fairly certain that the ostracizer will not make contact again. More than this though, I am not sure his silence has actually taken any real effort.
In my opinion, people who dole out the silent treatment are passive aggressive and possess very poor communicaitons skills. Further still, poor coping skills in the face of a counter argument or point.
My own recovery from what can not be over-stated as extreme devastation led me to reading about Personality Disorders. I strongly feel that verbal abusers (ironic but true for silent treatment inflictors) are largely NPD. Narcissistic Personality Disordered. They are emotionally under-cooked and pathologically selfish. They lack impulse control and don’t see people as anything more than objects (Object Constancy issues). Only someone with severe PD issues can cut and run from someone they cherished only the day before. All the splitting, painting black…where someone is either all good or all bad…are genuine indicators of this illness.
Ostracism is brutal in the negation of everything you had understood yourself to be and requires a ground-up rebuilding of esteem and self-worth. Ultimately, you get to a place of pity for the inflictor as they flit from one r/ship to another….fearing both intimacy and abandonment so being the one to initiate the latter and the expense of ever learning to really do the former.
I am not sure I could feel the ostracism so viscerally if it happened again. The gift of the Narcissist is learning to know yourself and to not believe for a moment any of the things their silence is meant to imply. And that strength doesn’t go away so easily
cheers,
Blair

I was suddenly, cruelly discarded by my BP BF of 2 years almost a year ago. This man is 58 and has a very high IQ. I am also in my late 50′s.
> I saw red flags over the years, something was not quite right, but had no idea what I was dealing with. Never even heard of BPD. Had I known I would have been able to protect my heart. I really believed he was the one I would spend the rest of my life with. . After reading and counseling I can see in hindsight, how his behavior was so predictable. The idealization, devaluation, and discarding. The projecting, splitting…….. Perceived criticisms that would escalate into rages. He let me know I was the problem; I was abusive, controlling……. He could never comfort me when he reduced me to tears. Instead he would tell me I was desperate when I cried. He never apologized. All these behaviors pecked at my soul.
>
> He was never happy. He wanted to live on a sailboat one month, build his own home the next and then wanted to live an ascetic life and rent a room from someone the next. He sailed for one week at sea. When he returned he said it was too hard a life. Six months later he said he wanted to live on a boat again, that he wasn’t in the right frame of mine when he was at sea.
> I never knew what was fantasy and what was reality.
>
> Three months ago during a telephone conversation he responded to a perceived criticism, Said I didn’t support him when he was offered a 1 year job out of state. I love(d) this man.
> I supported him. I just was not willing to sell my home and leave my job for a one year job with the clause that he could be let go within that year with a 24hour notice. I tried so hard to explain my innocence. He “threw the kitchen sink” at me during this phone call. Crazy talk. i.e.: From not supporting a move out of state, to how many times did we eat outdoors on the patio?
>
> He hung up on me and told me “never to call this number again”. I e-mailed him twice. He did not respond. Long story short, he quit his job, threw or gave away everything that he could not fit in his car, sold his home and moved out of state.
>
> I was devastated by the break up. No closure and the silent treatment is the ABSOLUTE WORSE form of emotional abuse. My self esteem was shattered.

>
>
>

Leave a comment.

Comments go live after a short delay. Thank you for contributing.

(required)

(required)