After Committing a Crime, Guilt and Shame Predict Re-Offense

Within three years of being released from jail, two out of every three inmates in the US wind up behind bars again — a problem that contributes to the highest incarceration rate of any country in the world. New research suggests that the degree to which inmates’ express guilt or shame may provide an indicator of how likely they are to re-offend.

The findings show that inmates who feel guilt about specific behaviors are more likely to stay out of jail later on, whereas those that are inclined to feel shame about the self might not.

This research is published in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.

The difference between guilt and shame might seem subtle, but researcher June Tangney and her colleagues Jeffrey Stuewig and Andres Martinez of George Mason University hypothesized that feeling one or the other of these emotions might contribute to different outcomes for incarcerated individuals.

“When people feel guilt about a specific behavior, they experience tension, remorse, and regret,” the researchers write. “Research has shown that this sense of tension and regret typically motivates reparative action — confessing, apologizing, or somehow repairing the damage done.”

Feelings of shame, on the other hand, involve a painful feeling directed toward the self. For some people, feelings of shame lead to a defensive response, a denial of responsibility, and a need to blame others — a process that can lead to aggression.

Tangney and her colleagues interviewed over 470 inmates, asking them about their feelings of guilt, shame, and externalization of blame soon after they were incarcerated. The researchers followed up with 332 of the offenders a year after they had been released, this time asking them whether they had been arrested again and whether they had committed a crime but had not been caught. They also compared the self-reported data to official arrest records.

Overall, expressions of guilt and shame were associated with recidivism rates, but in different ways.

“Proneness to guilt predicts less recidivism — a lower likelihood of re-offense,” Tangney says. That is, the more inclined an inmate is to feel guilt, the less likely he or she is to re-offend.

The implications of proneness to shame, on the other hand, were more complex.

Inmates inclined to feel shame, and who were also defensive and blameful of others, were more likely to slip back into crime. Inmates who were shameful but who didn’t blame others were less likely to end up in jail again.

These findings suggest that there may be “two faces” of shame — one that increases recidivism and one that does just the opposite.

“It has implications for intervention for the more than 13 million individuals who pass through our nation’s jails and prisons annually,” says Tangney. “We hope that inmates will ultimately benefit from treatment enhanced by an appreciation for the positive potential of guilt, and an appreciation for the ‘two faces’ of shame.”

The researchers believe this work opens up doors for evaluating other aspects of restorative justice, and they plan to investigate the links between guilt, shame, and other post-release outcomes, including substance abuse, mental health issues, and readjustment into their communities.

Comments

I believe that it is true. Shame can manifest itself in the blaming of others and not taking responsibility for self

Sometimes guilt is a way of learning that never do it again. Start over

who is the author that wrote this, please?

June P. Tangney

As a public spirited person who work as a Chairperson of Parole Board Thohoyandou in South Africa, I feel the lesson I got from this topic of Guilt and Shame has enhenced my knowledge and understanding of why offenders from oir centers go out from the centre and come back with new warrants of crimes committed while on parole. The lessons also gave me an insight into how to prevent this feom happening. As parole Advocate, I feel I have a duty to see to it that offenders or parolees are doing well outside.

I am of the opinion that this peaces of researh must be publicised in deferent medias and newspapers, magazines and other public instruments.

I think that after committing crimes and bailed or realeased from jail that police are more biligerent and hash to the people with criminal records, this may be why they seem to go back to jail.

Shame can go another way. Blaming yourself. Years of unworthiness and hatred for youself can do so much damage. Acting out in criminally for me became an addiction, an emotional release. I was a shoplifter. It gave me the same comfort as my drug and alcohol abuse. Ive hated myself as long as I remember. I trust noone with my story of PTSD and the result of it. 12 step programs made my pain worse.Im seeking someone I can trust that may have compassion for my situation and not condemnation. Wish us all luck.

Leave a Reply to Jack Ford Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.
In the interest of transparency, we do not accept anonymous comments.
Required fields are marked*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.